M.F. Rahman vs. Ali Sina 

Page 3

2005/03/08

Back   <   >   Next

Dear Ali Sina,

Greetings.

You say that Muhammad is the problem.

Yet it was only when you read the Quran you decided against Islam.
Which was the deciding factor really? 

If you have left Islam which you never really knew by your own admission, unless you have become an atheist, you have accepted another faith. You have crossed that bridge already. 

You and I are in the valley of discussing religion. Why your reluctance to advise your faith and deity? Yet, if you feel that is mature, let it be.  

Those who follow Muhammad err in that they do not separate his pre-revelation practices from his post revelation period. To condemn anyone for his pre-reformation behaviour is perverse. Rather, you should try to teach Muslims to follow Quran's teachings, and even so you need to separate pre-Islamic establishment verses from post.

But I do not believe that you would be interested in that.  

I must disappoint you in that I am not concerned with proving the self evident. Others are free to hold as warped perspectives as God is pleased to inspire them for His Purpose.

Your site will last exactly as long as God Wills.

Regarding the Ummah, it is as most others. Very few know in depth what their beliefs are.  Many follow faiths by inheritance. You may seek to exploit that as much as you please. 

As you claim I misunderstood your theoretical whoring mother, you have misunderstood my reference to The Omnipotent God. That is The God, not merely "my" God.

So I would repeat :- "And if you believed in God, you would also understand that He is in Omnipotent control of every minutiae of detail. Your efforts will neither aid nor obstruct Him. They will simply ensure the destiny He has Written for you." What is your understanding of God my friend? 

Know that Muhammad is deemed The Prophet by the Quran. If you reject the Quran,  you would reject him logically. No other proof applies. 

The Quran corrects him in several places and admits his faults and forgives him as well. Whatever he had been is now irrelevant. You of course would seek to make it relevant. Even though most of your allegations against him are simply exaggerated untruths, he has been forgiven completely in the promise of the Quran. Discussing him is irrelevant. 

How can I help you further? 

mfr.

Back   <   >   Next