| |
Readers' comments
page 15
1. 2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
11. 12. 13.
14. 15. 16.
17. 18. 19.
20. 21
22 23
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
A personal campaign of a Muslim woman
Dear
Muslims;
Do you know
that most Muslims are ignorant of most of the Islamic history and most of
what is in Quran and hadeeses. The religious leaders and moulanas, who
have done detailed study, leave out many objectionable facts from their
writings and speeches to avoid creating doubts in inquisitive and smart
minds because they want to maintain their influence and job or as a
service to Islam for sawab.
When
confronted with some thorny issues and facts by the few Muslims and non
Muslims who do make these studies they tend to sugarcoat the facts and
give answers like "you do not know real Islam", "It is out
of context", "Arabic cannot be translated correctly in other
languages so you cannot get the real facts by reading translations",
"It was the tribal custom of those days", "the hadeeses are
not reliable", "it is metaphorical statement and doesn’t mean
what it seems" or simply lie if they are not sure how to prove their
point. If you want to know the facts and educate yourself you have to
study and critically analyze the scriptures yourself with a mind unfogged
with blind faith and fear of hellfire and then form your opinion. One of
the faster ways is to go on the websites of scholars who were born as
Muslims, and have spent a long time studying Islam and support their
findings and conclusions with authentic references so that you can check
them out. Some of these sites are secularislam.org, realislam.org and
faithfreedom.org.
It
is widely feared that blind faith and fanaticism will cause fanatics to
attack U.S.A with weapons of mass destruction, if that happens needless to
say that it will trigger WW III and no one will be safe. Only education
and enlightenment can prevent this disaster from happening. You can help
by forwarding this e-mail to your e-mail list of friends and
acquaintances.
Ayesha
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06/25/02
which is verse 2:178
YUSUFALI: O ye who believe! the law of equality is prescribed to you
in cases of murder: the free for the free, the slave for the slave,
the woman for the woman. But if any remission is made by the brother
of the slain, then grant any reasonable demand, and compensate him
with handsome gratitude, this is a concession and a Mercy from your
Lord. After this whoever exceeds the limits shall be in grave
penalty.
This means
1. If a slave is killed by a free man,
then the innocent slave
of the killer
free man has to be killed (who is not the
killer)
2. If a female is killed by a male,
then a female (probably owned
by the killer
male) has to be killed
Is there any way an apologist can defend this as the word of God?
I have never seen any critic of the scriptures point out this verse
in any refutation. This may be the only one you need to put the
kibosh on!
Rationalist
"Henri Henri" <[email protected]>
Sun, 30 Jun 2002
Subject: |
Ali, you have just proved my
point |
I quote you a set of comments made in your
comments section, by somebody posing as a "Rationalist". BTW,
why do you not choose to publish the emails of non-Muslims who send
comments but Muslims who do so you leave there emails for everyone to
see. Again just goes to prove my poin that you are extremely immature,
and a plain coward. I want to refute the nonsense of
"Rationalist" therefore would be grateful if you could ask
him/her to get in touch with me.
06/25/02
which is verse 2:178
---------------------------------------------------
"I have never seen any critic of the
scriptures point out this verse in any refutation."
Let the idiot know that the reason no critic
has ever raised this is because the critic is able to comprehend what is
being said, unlike Mr "Rationalist".
There is nothing to refute here the fact remains Mr
"Rationalist" mind is plagued with nonsense, bad intention and
hate - he has grasped the true meaning in the most wrong way possible.
Ali, do you pay any heed???
This child-like reading is very indicitive of a
major dilemma America faces today – dysfunctional illiteracy, i.e. the
average American can read and pronounce words but has absolutely no clue
as to what it is telling them.
Ali, I sincerely ask you to wise up and not
just paste any old garbage from people posing as critics. The above
conclusion is beyond wild, and you know that. It is irrational, stupid
and plain childish. The verses narrate noting of the nature your
so-called friend "Rationalist" has made.
Our friend seems to think that ANY free man, or
ANY slave, or ANY female is allowed to be killed for retaliation. This
is stupidity at its highest. Nowhere does it make these inferences. The
free man who killed another free man is to be killed. The slave who
killed another slave is to be killed. The female who kills another
female must be killed.
Looks like your "Rationalist" friend
needs a dose of prozac. Unless you feel the someway...if so come and
refute us, and explain why YOU never noticed this supposed teaching of
the Quran throughout your "many" years as a Muslim.
Thank
you.
Ali Sina Responds:
Dear "mature" Henri Henri,
I cannot post the emails of the people who
criticize Islam. This would jeopardize their lives. Muslims kill those
who criticize their religion. Isn't this a convincing reason in your
opinion? I even change the name of those who send their
testimonials as apostates.
Now can you please tell us why Allah needed to
specify a slave for a slave, a freeman for a freeman and a female
for a female? What should be done when a slave kills a freeman? What is
the punishment of a free man who kills a slave? What if a man kill a
woman? Why Allah did not just say kill the one who kills another human
being? Have you thought of it?
Of course Muslims never practiced this law.
This is the most blatantly stupid law of the Quran that no one put it in
practice. Fortunately most Muslims, just like you, believe that the
meaning of this verse is something different than its obvious
meaning. The majority of Muslims are in denial.
The reason I did not notice this blatantly
unjust teaching in my many years as a believer is because I did not read
the Quran and was not aware of it. This is unfortunately the problem
with most Muslims. All Muslims chant the Quran daily but no one
understands what they are reading. Even if I had read it, I probably
would have brushed it off just like you, giving it a meaning
different from the obvious.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06/24/02
Hello,
I see we share a common goal and was wondering if we could share links
on one another's websites.
A bit about myself and how I came to become a Kafir:
Anti-Jihad was born shortly before the Sept 11th attacks on the US.
I was not aware of their existence until after the 9/11 attacks.
Since I suffered personal losses (8 former co-workers and friends murdered
in the Pentagon) I took it upon myself and had to seek some assistance.
I retired from the US Navy in Feb 2000 (I worked closely with a Naval
Communications Center at the Pentagon; this is where the plane hit).
Through anger and determination of seeking help from others on the web, I
discovered Anti-Jihad back in October of last year. Since then, I
have become the North American Branch Leader of the group. We are a
non-violent, non-terrorist group. We are represented on every
continent except Antarctica. We spread word of ourselves using the
Internet and email. We fight using the pen and not the sword.
Thanks!
A2ndCrusader
North American Branch of Anti-Jihad
HOW LONG? NOT LONG! FOR WHAT YOU REAP IS WHAT YOU SOW!
http://www.geocities.com/jihadisucks/index.html
Dear 2nd crusader,
Thank you for your email. I
added the link to your site in my link page. I also chose your site as the
Site of The Week and placed a link to it from my main page.
I surly applaud your resolve to
fight this evil that is hitting your country and I regret to hear about
the loss of your friends in the Pentagon. I also lost my dear friends to
Islam after the Islamic Revolution, ethical people who were guiding lamps
to humanity.
There was also a time when my
country (Iran) was the only superpower of the world. We wrote the first
Charter of Human Rights. We freed enslaved nations like the Jews and
helped them to return to their land and build their temples and worship
their gods. In all the vast Iranian Empire all people were free to worship
their god and practice their religion. There was freedom of thoughts. We
had “Good deeds, good words and good thoughts” as our motto. Our women
enjoyed equal rights and some of them even reined our great land. Our god
was Ahura Mazda, a god of mercy and of benevolence. But today we worship
Allah, this Arab deity of hate and vengeance. As the result we are the
prime abusers of human rights; we have relegated women to 2nd
class citizens. We discriminate against religious minorities. Today we are
a primitive, backward and poor nation. Today we are a terrorist nation.
Today there is a shame associated to our name. Today we are a disgrace to
human race. This is all thanks to Islam.
Dear friend, Islam destroyed my
country 1400 years ago and today Muslims have set their eyes on your
country. If anyone thinks that America is immune to Islamic poison he is a
fool. The Muslims are here and they are infiltrating in the lands once
called Christendom. They are pouring millions of dollars into their
propaganda machinery, building mosques and brainwashing your kids. They
are converting your children into terrorists who hate their motherland and
will sell or rather destroy her to appease this Arab deity of hate.
Today Muslims are making
Islamic bombs. Pakistan has many of them and within 20 years their number
will be over 1000. Iran according to a Russian General has already the
atomic bomb. Iraq has been making chemical and biological weapons of mass
destruction for years. Have you ever imagined what if all these countries
load their commercial ships and passenger-jets with their arsenals and
send them to thousands of North American and European cities and nuke all
of them in a single day?
If any one thinks this scenario
is not possible or is science fiction he is a damn fool who knows nothing
about Islam and how the Muslim mind works. Did you hear Al-Qa'ida
Spokesman Explaining September 11 and Declaring Intentions to Kill 4
Million Americans with Weapons of Mass Destruction? Read this
The MAD Mutual Assured Destruction that worked as
détente during the cold war has no meaning for Islamists. They are ready
to kill themselves as long as they kill more of the Kafirs. Islam is a
cult that celebrates death. Devout Muslims pray for martyrdom. They
consider their desire to die for their religion as the sign of their faith
to Allah and his messenger. Take a look at this link and see how the
mother of a suicide bomber rejoices in the death of her son and sheds
tears of joy for his success in murdering ten Israelis and wounding many
more. She says "Jihad is a [religious]
commandment imposed upon us. We must instill this idea in our sons' souls,
all the time” and ads "Allah
be praised, I am a Muslim and I believe in Jihad. Jihad is one of the
elements of the faith and this is what encouraged me to sacrifice Muhammad
in Jihad for the sake of Allah. My son was not destroyed, he is not dead;
he is living a happier life than I. Had my thoughts been limited to this
world, I would not sacrifice Muhammad." Read
it, it will shock you. http://memri.org/bin/latestnews.cgi?ID=SD39102
This sick mentality is shared by all Muslims who truly believe in this
cult of death. The worst thing we can do is doing nothing. Can we afford
that?
But I am not suggesting we
should nuke them first preemptively. That would be ludicrous. We cannot go
killing millions of innocent human beings based on our fears. Yet these
fears are real and we have to do something. The United State wants to
expend billions of dollars to fight terrorism. At the same time the
President gives assurance that "this is not about Islam" and
that "Islam is a religion of peace". But the truth is that this
is about Islam and Islam is not a religion of peace. In your site you make
emphasis on Islamic "extremism". The problem is that Islamic
extremism is the real Islam. Those Muslims who are not extremists are not
Muslims. They are wishy-washy believers who know nothing about Islam and
do not practice it.
Sir, if you want to fight
Islamic extremism, if you want to fight Islamic terrorism you have to
fight Islam. Islam cannot be reformed. This was tried for over a century
and failed. Islam cannot be humanized because, as one Muslim put it,
“Islam is a non-humanistic religion par excellence”. Islam has no
respect for human rights or human lives. Islam is about worshipping a
deity that craves for blood, is vengeful and is unforgiving. Unlike what
Islamic propagandists claim Islam does not mean “peace”, it means
submission to Allah, this god of hate, and his psychopath messenger.
So you ask what can we do. The
answer is we can destroy Islam. We can destroy this cult of ignorance and
win Muslims as our friends and allies. Yes Islam can be eradicated and
believe it or not it is the fastest, the easiest, the most effective and
the most humane way to combat terrorism. Islamic terrorism is inspired by
Islamic theology. But Islamic theology is based on total lies. Once you
disprove that theology, the whole edifice of Islam will come down like a
house of cards.
Muslims are humans too. Once
they see that Islam is nothing but a huge lie, they will leave this cult
in big numbers. Once that happens, Islam will crumble under its own weight
just as communism did. Do not look at the fanaticism of Muslims today.
Despite this zealotry or perhaps because of it, Islam is extremely
vulnerable. Islam is vulnerable because it is based on total lies. We can
destroy it with truth.
Our site is doing just that. We
want to spread the truth. We want to educate Muslims about the real Islam.
We fight this darkness of ignorance with the light of knowledge. And we
will be successful because knowledge is more powerful than ignorance as
light is more potent than darkness.
I believe we have to work
together. We have to be organized and work systematically in order to slay
this devil. What we have to do is to make our message reach far and wide.
But we are just a few people. Our enemy is powerful and has billions of
dollars to expend in their propaganda campaign of lies and deceit. While
we have to rely on our own meager resources. This is more than the battle
of David versus Goliath. We have taken upon ourselves to eradicate a
religion that is professed by over a billion of people, is funded with
billions of dollars and whose brainwashed followers are ready, willing and
able to kill anyone who opposes it.
I invite you to join us, let us
put our heads together and see how we can make our message reach the
world. We need to translate the faithfreedom.org and its articles to many
languages; we need to have a radio, create TV documentaries and much more.
I promise that if we do our homework, if we can reach all the Muslims with
our message, soon millions of them will walk away from Islam, This weakens
the faith of the more hardcore Muslims and eventually Islam will fall
apart.
Islam will be eradicated within
30 years. This is what I said a year ago. I am aware that with this claim
I risk not being taken seriously and being looked upon as a wishful thinker and an
idealist. But I am neither. I am also not a psychic. I consider the
events and foresee the fall of Islam within 30 yeas in the same way a
meteorologist foresees the coming of a tempest. Either we will be
successful and can weaken Islam from within so it falls apart like
communism did or we do nothing and Islam will destroy half of the world
killing more than half of humanity and then it will be destroyed like
Nazism was destroyed, with a vengeance. Whatever happens it will happen in
these thirty coming years. These would be the most eventful years of human
history. The Muslims, all around the world are preparing themselves for
the big Jihad that would thwart the first and second World Wars. Their own
destruction does not matter to them because they believe Allah will
protect them and will make them victorious.
We either do nothing and let them destroy the humanity in their
madness, or educate them, weaken their faith and eliminate their
motivation to do more harm.
The members of Faith Freedom
International believe that the second option is better. We know this is
doable and we are working towards that goal. But we are a small group with
limited resources. If you know people who can help us make our message
heard please contact them. Please ask them to contact us. We have to reach
the innocent youth in Islamic world before the terrorists reach them and
convert them into suicide killers. We have to make our message heard by
all the Muslims. Do you think you can help?
Kind regards
Ali Sina
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06/23/02
Dear Mr. Sina,
I recently paid a visit to your web site under the
recommendation of a friend. I have to say I strongly agree with the
majority of your views regarding Islam and most other religions.
However, I would like to take this opportunity and
say that your site would provide more of an enlightening experience if you
would portray more of a balanced view regarding intrinsic flaws in Islamic
doctrine and how it is and has been exploited for peoples own gains.
Moreover, I would like to point out that Islamic
Fundamentalism, in certain circumstances, has been nurtured by foreign
powers such as the American CIA for its own nefarious designs. This is not
a conspiracy theory but a well-known fact. People such as Saddam Hussien
and Osama Bin Laden have been funded by the CIA and used for their own
purposes such as causing secession in the former USSR and conflict with
Iran. The fundamentalist
movement in Afghanistan was jointly devised by the Pakistani
ISI (intelligence agency) and the American CIA during
the cold war. Its initial objective was to repel the Soviet invaders.
However, due to the success of the mujahideen against the soviets the CIA
continued with the program but this time sent mujahideen to Soviet
republics with Muslim majorities in order to create secession (might I add
just like we are
seeing in Chechnya). The aid to the mujahideen was
flowing into Afghanistan several years before the Soviets invaded and
continued for! many years after resulting in th
These are just some of the more obvious incidences
where by a hostile or corrupt Islam has been advantageous for the West.
However, I’m not intimating that the west is culpable for all the ills
of the Muslim world because there are many aspects of Islam that result in
fundamentalism and can be seen through out Islamic history. The main point
of this correspondence is to highlight that your web site at times seems
to be ignoring the fact that some of the problems, which the Muslim world
is facing, is due to foreign involvement, which is most evident in the
Middle East.
Yours sincerely,
A Concerned Individual
Ali Sina Responds:
You are absolutely right sir. It
is time that the American public see how their tax money was and is being
expended, supporting puppet governments and rearing terrorists all around
the world. And now the smoke of the fire that these very American
governments have started is catching up to them and is burning their eyes.
But worse than American are the Europeans headed by they British who had
never any respect for human rights and would rather support the
most corrupt governments as long as they can sign lucrative deals with
them. At
least the US government acknowledges that some of its old policies were
mistaken and avoids dealing with the most terrorist governments such as
the Islamic Republic of Iran, but the Europeans and especially the Brits
thumb their nose at the Human Rights reports coming from Iran and keep
making deals with the terrorists that have usurped the power in that
country. It is a shame that the government of a country with such a long
history of democracy, is so shamelessly in cahoots with the thugs and
terrorists out side its borders.
06/24/02
Dear Mr. Sina,
Firstly I would like to thank you for putting my message on your web
site. Secondly I would like to say that your comments regarding the
British are correct to a certain extent however the US and Britain can be
though of one entity when it concerns geo-politics. Their interests are very
much linked and their intelligence and various military establishments are
quite integrated.
The following is an excerpt
from your reply which I do not agree with at all and reads as follows:
“At least the US government
acknowledges that some of its old policies were mistaken and avoids
dealing with the most terrorist governments such as the Islamic Republic
of Iran”
First of all the US government
aren’t naive or stupid people who don’t know that their dealings with
certain governments will result in the torment and destruction of the
people of that nation. On the contrary the US government knows full well
the implications of their actions, their only concern is to gain an
advantage be that economic or political.
I would like to draw your
attention towards a terrorist camp devised by the US government in its own
back yard in the state of Georgia. The name of the camp was S.O.A (School
of Americas) however it’s name has been changed to WHISC (Western
Hemisphere Institute for Security Co-operation). The following are
excerpts from an article, regarding the aforementioned terrorist camp,
which appeared in the British paper. The Guardian, on October 30, 2001 and
can be viewed in its entirety at the following address:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/waronterror/story/0,1361,583254,00.html
"If any government
sponsors the outlaws and killers of innocents," George Bush announced
on the day he began bombing Afghanistan, "they have become outlaws
and murderers themselves. And they will take that lonely path at their own
peril." I'm glad he said "any government", as there's one
which, though it has yet to be identified as a sponsor of terrorism,
requires his urgent attention.
For the past 55 years it has
been running a terrorist training camp, whose victims massively outnumber
the people killed by the attack on New York, the embassy bombings and the
other atrocities laid, at al-Qaida's door. The camp is called the Western
Hemisphere Institute for Security Co-operation, or WHISC. It is based in
Fort Benning, Georgia, and it is funded by Mr Bush's government.
Until January 2001, WHISC was
called the "School of the Americas", or SOA. Since 1946, SOA has
trained more than 60,000 Latin American soldiers and policemen. Among its
graduates are many of the continent's most notorious torturers, mass
murderers, dictators and state terrorists. As hundreds of pages of
documentation compiled by the pressure group SOA Watch shows, Latin
America has been ripped apart by its graduates.
Last year, partly as a result
of the campaign run by SOA Watch, several US congressmen tried to shut the
school down. They were defeated by 10 votes. Instead, the House of
Representatives voted to close it and then immediately reopen it under a
different name.
This terrorist camp is still
in operation today. Now Mr. Sina my question is, have the US government
acknowledged that some of its old policies were mistaken? If you’re
still in doubt please read the above article in its entirety and also
research US involvement in Guatemala, Peru, Chile, etc. The US aren’t
Muslim are they?
Yours sincerely,
A
Concerned Individual
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06/21/02
Dear
Mr. Sina,
I have read many of your articles, and I can feel your sincerity toward
humanity, so I begin to think if there is something I can do for you,
though I don't know you personally and never I come to your country.
After many thoughts, I determine to give you a cup of information for help
you in dealing with the people who have blind faith to their "scientific" religion. Perhaps The Buddha can help them find the
light.
In
the Kalama Sutra, we find the Kalamas (tribe), a people of apparently
skeptical natures, asking Buddha for guidance in distinguishing good
teachers from bad ones, and proper teachings from evil ones. The
Buddha answers in three parts, which are treasures of wisdom. He
outlines the criteria we should use to distinguish good from bad
teachers and teachings:
"It is proper for you, Kalamas, to doubt, to be uncertain.... Do
not go upon what has been acquired by repeated hearing; nor upon
tradition; nor upon rumor; nor upon what is in a scripture; nor upon
surmise; nor upon an axiom; nor upon specious reasoning; nor upon a
bias towards a notion that has been pondered over; nor upon another's
seeming ability; nor upon the consideration, 'The monk is our
teacher....' "
"What do you think, Kalamas? Does greed appear in a man for his
benefit or harm? Does hate appear in a man for his benefit or harm?
Does delusion appear in a man for his benefit or harm?"
The Kalamas answered, "For his harm, venerable sir."
"Kalamas, being given to greed, hate, and delusion, and being
overwhelmed and vanquished mentally by greed, hate, and delusion, this
man takes life, steals, commits adultery, and tells lies; he prompts
another too, to do likewise. Will that be long for his harm and
ill?"
The Kalamas answered, "Yes, venerable sir...."
"Kalamas, when you yourselves know: 'These things are bad; these
things are blamable; these things are censured by the wise; undertaken
and observed, these things lead to harm and ill,' abandon them. "
Mr. Sina this is just a cup of help from a simple person like me. I
hope it will become a benefit for you and humanity.
Thank you for your attention, Sir.
>From : Qitth Aswad
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
June 20 2002
Greetings,
I am becoming addicted to your website, which is very educational. I
admire your strong will and courage towards this cause, with which I
agree. I'd like to present a few points and questions to you.
I suppose that I am an agnostic. I am a Catholic medical student and
would like to have a stronger faith, but just cannot seem to do it. I
don't lose sleep over this state of being and just try to be as kind
and
loving as possible. If there's a God, then I would think, assuming He
cares, that He can differentiate between who is good and bad. On the
other hand, I haven't totally abandoned the usefulness of religion,
which can be used for both good and evil, and as a means of holding
communities and civilizations together. I think that a healthy society
is one that has struck the right combination between faith and secular
matters.
Extremes in either direction, toward the religious or secular, tend to
produce pathological societies. The 20th century was a prime example
of
the triumph of both atheism and the state. The result was
industrialized bloodshed and suffering on an unimaginable scale. The
wars and genocides of Lenin, Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, etc. are
unsurpassed by all of previous history. If religion is the opiate of
the masses, then socialism is the opiate of tyrants. Ironically, as
religions in the West lost political power, they gained in their
humanitarian aspect. Therefore, I think that it is not religion that
causes human misery, but any sort of ideology run amok - something in
our human condition. Jared Diamond, in The Third Chimpanzee, writes
about how chimpanzees and other primates have been seen to wage
primitive wars between groups and to commit genocide. Since our
primate
cousins do not have advanced abstract thinking abilities, they do not
need ideology to spur them on to violence. Their biological nature
compels such behavior. Whereas we human beings are compelled to
violence by our animal instinct as well as our ability to come up with
all sorts of various ideas that justify violence. Man, in his
primitive
state, could only come up with primitive explanations for the world
through religion. Man, in his post-industrialized state and more
advanced society, can come up with more sophisticated political
theories
and models, such as communism, that often lead to violence. Who knows
what nonsense the great political thinkers of tomorrow will come up
with.
In regards to Islam, I have a few concerns.
Muslims are not likely to accept a message like yours from Westerners.
However, after reading some of your debates with Muslims, I am not
encouraged. The people writing to you have access to computers, some
degree of money and financial freedom. They are, therefore, probably
among the relatively more educated. The fact that some people try to
justify the abuse of nine year old Aisha, for example, by claiming
girls
enter puberty earlier in warm climates is extremely disturbing. Anyone
with the least bit of knowledge of evolution, genetics, and general
biology knows that this is laughable. The debate you had with
Ayatollah
Montazeri wasn't exactly close. If he represents one of the most
respected religious voices in Iran, that is scary.
How are you and like-minded people going to make any significant
headway
against the stubborn reactionary mentality of many Muslims. If you are
having difficulty with the higher-ups, then how can you possible reach
those without access to the outside world and to communication? How
can
you convince young, desperate, unemployed, and angry youths to not
join
a terrorist group or to engage in jihad?
It would be an immense relief to me if you are indeed making headway
with like-minded individuals. Is there a decent sized network that you
all maintain in order to encourage each other and foster ideas and
debate? Do you really believe that Islam is as weak as you had
maintained and that it will likely cease to exist (I don't remember
where I read that line from your text)?
The reason I worry is because I think that there is a race between
Islam's ability to be reformed internally and a clash between
civilizations. Eventually the people of the West, and perhaps the
entire non-Muslim world, will themselves become desperate, afraid, and
angry enough to strike back ferociously against all of Islam. Even
pacifist Europe, traumatized from having fought so many wars, is
beginning to become increasingly anti-Islamic, as the recent wave of
right wing political victories indicate. Europeans are going to become
more and more afraid of being overwhelmed in their own countries by
Islamic immigrants. We may not have seen the last religious war in
Europe (likewise I wouldn't be surprised to see an emergence of a
vehement reactionary Christianity in response to fear generated by
Islam).
Perhaps I am too pessimistic. But I think that you are too far ahead
of
the curve. The most successful leaders are often not those too far
beyond the capacities of the average person. Extremely intelligent
people or those who present too sudden a dramatic change are not often
followed by the masses because they cannot relate to such a person.
Therefore, I believe that the uneducated and bigoted mullahs, as well
as
the charismatic and bigoted terrorists will always have a larger
following than you and your allies - just as more people will watch
sitcoms than C-Span.
I am not optimistic. Have a great day and good luck to you and your
friends!
Sincerely,
Martin
PS - I'm glad to see you mention that pre-Islamic Iran was one of the
great classical civilizations of history. The Arabs were mostly
backwater peoples, barbarians on the fringes of civilization. The
snuffing out of the great civilizations of the Near East, such as
Mesopotamia, Egypt, and Iran, by Islam is a true shame and loss to
humanity. I have often wondered if there is any residual resentment of
injured national pride felt by the people of Iran and the other
countries in the area.
I had also come to a similar conclusion about monotheism and
polytheism
as you have. There weren't any religious wars in polytheistic
antiquity before the advent of the Abrahamic religions in the West and Near
East.
The world was much more tolerant.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
June 20 2002
Jawad wrote:
Is ibn Warraq from Iran...? and are you from
Iran...I have noticed a lot of Iranians are hostile to Islam why?
Thanks
Jawad
Answer:
Ibn Warraq is from Indian
subcontinent. I am not sure which country.
Most Iranians are against Islam
now because they saw the real Islam during these 23 years of Islamic rule.
At first they said, this is not the real Islam and Mullahs are doing
unIslamic things. Some still say so. But more and more Iranians are
learning about Islam and they realize this is the real Islam. That is why
they leave it.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
June 17, 2002
I recently stumbled upon your website while
trying to learn more about Islam. I have had much difficulty finding
any information about Islam other than the Qoran (sp?) and some odd,
malformed texts. Your
website has given me a clearer picture of Islam and what it is doing
to the world. I have always been against organized religion because of
many reasons. (Control, logic, fanaticism, etc...). Now I can add
Islam to my long list of religions that are based on human needs
rather than logic or reason.
I read your feedback section on 'what muslims think of me' and I had
to chuckle. It seems that it doesn't matter what religion, faith, or
nationality people are, they still have a blind devotion to what they
are told to believe. While growing up, I got into many debates with
christian followers and leaders, and many of the debates went along
the same logic that your critics seem to have. (Or is that lack of
logic...)
Anyway, thank you for having this site up, and please know that there
are surely many people who think and feel the same way that you do.
Patrick Dickey
BTW: Has anyone tried your challenge yet?
Yes
of course. Here is the debates I had
with them
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|

|
 |
 |
June 14, 2002
Dear Dr.
Sina,
I have
spent the last 5 hours reading things in your web-site...and I am no where
near finished. A couple of things I would like you to know about me.
First, I do not have anywhere near your education or ability to so
succinctly state your views. Second, I was raised as a
Christian...Southern Baptist to be exact. I've never really been a
believer. I broke away from that at about age 10 when no one
could give me a good answer to the question "If God loved his Son,
why did he let him be brutally murdered?" The sacrifice on
the cross for sins never did make sense to me. After all, God's
supposed to be a lot smarter...couldn't there have been another way
to be forgiven? My apologies...I digress.
I came
your site because I've been researching, actually, let me put this more
succinctly, trying to disprove the statement of a Christian friend that
the religion of Islam is the most dangerous threat to the world today.
You see, I have Muslim friends who are the most gentle and loving people
that I know. My dear friend Fatima is like a sister to me. I
perceived negative statements about Islam in the context of the woman I
know and her family. I could tell you so many stories of the
loving-kindness these people have shown me. I certainly bought the
mythology of Islam as a peaceful religion because my only real exposure to
it has been through these good people. Even after 9/11...after
all...those were just crazed maniacs who weren't "true"
believers.
I started
my research by going to Islamic sites and reading about the religion.
These sites were mostly educational. Focusing on the peaceful nature
of Islam...quoting verses from the Quran the propagated that image.
So...I consulted my friends and bought an English translation of the Quran
that they selected for me. I started to read the Quran and very soon
the rot set in. I confess that after I read that a woman can be
beaten (lightly) by her husband if he suspects her of bad behavior,
I didn't go much further. I kept trying to go back and read it but
another problem I had is that it just didn't make much sense. I
couldn't find any organization...couldn't follow a flow. Couldn't
really make any sense out of it. I thought the fault was my western
mind set, so I returned to the internet. Looking for instructions on
how to read the Quran. Talked with my friends about it...and that's
when I was told about the writings of the scholars (hadith? forgive me,
after five hours in the website my mind is a bit fuzzy around the edges
and I think my eyes have popped out of their sockets and are hanging
somewhere around my hipbones) and how the Quran was
organized...chapters by length instead of any chronological order.
So, I dived back in...found some websites with the writings...and was
still confused...and more...deeply troubled by what I was reading.
After a
month of that and still not a 10th of the way through the Quran (I kept
going back and re-reading things, trying to make sense) I took
another approach. Back to the web. I looked to Islamic sites
that would disprove what my Christian friend said. Particularly what
she said about the strange silence of Muslims about the suicide bombings
in Israel and the lukewarm condemnations of 9/11. I
couldn't find anything that supported my view point. I have yet to
find a single Islamic site that condemns the suicide terrorists. And
while American Muslim sites were passionate in condemning 9/11, sites from
other countries were indeed lukewarm...or worse...supportive. I
found some of the most horrible things. One site has pictures of
dead and malformed babies in Iraq...all the fault of the US...no mention
of Hussein and his repression. This site clearly states that all
democratic or republican governments are wrong...and that the whole world
should be under Islamic government. Very, very scary. I guess you've
seen those sites as well, and probably know about more of them than what I
found.
Through
yahoo I saw opposing viewpoints links..which led my to your site tonight.
As I said before, I've been in there for 5 hours...I just couldn't stop
reading. I had my copy of the Quran and looked up every quote I read
and compared it...and also verses before and after. Sir, I don't see
where you've taken things out of context at all. Your points are valid in
my mind.
I went
researching to prove someone wrong...and now I believe that I was
wrong...and now I don't know what to do. One thing, for certain, is
to go back to my Christian friend and apologize for calling her a bigot.
(We're still friends..her response to my heated remark was a slight smile
and "Prove it.") But what of my Muslim friends? I really
love these folks. I have seen the same attitudes in them that
you and others have described...one dare not question beliefs..one dare
not question the Quran. And I have not with them out of respect.
One part of me just wants to let it slide...I suppose that's cowardice.
Another part of me wants to show them the truth...but how?
Anyway, I
admire what you are doing with your website...and thank you for reading
this long babble.
Lynn
Ali Sina responds:
Dear Lynn,
Thank you for your kind email.
I am happy to learn that the articles I post here mostly written by
ex-Muslims are helping others to see the truth about Islam.
What you say about your Muslim
friend is not an exception but the rule. Most Muslims are wonderful
people. If they come from Middle East they are also very hospitable.
(Hospitality is of course a Middle Eastern quality; it has nothing to do
with Islam. People belonging to all religions in Middle East are
hospitable.). Good people are found in all societies and there is a good
percentage of that also among Muslims.
But at the same time you read
terrible things happening in Islamic countries and by devout Muslims
everywhere. The reason is that Islam converts good people into evils. The
purpose of my site is to inform the good Muslims about the real Islam and
help them leave this diabolic cult. Now
of course if you say this to your friend, you will most likely lose her as
a friend and wouldn’t’ it be a pity to lose such wonderful friend?
So instead of telling her that
you found out that Islam is a false religion, you may ask her to read some
of the articles of this site and help you understand it. Send her the URL
of some of the articles but do not say that you have already made your
mind. Let her read some of the articles posted in this site and let her
come to her own conclusions. She may not like what she reads and she may
stop reading it. Let her alone for a while and then ask her whether she
knows someone who can help you understand or refute the claims of this
site.
At Faith Freedom International
we have started a campaign to educate Muslims about Islam. We want our
message reach all the Muslims, she will hear of us again. If she is
sincere she will eventually come to see the truth. Islam is a religion in
fast demise. Soon it will be eradicated and millions of Muslims will be
freed. Your friend is going to be one of them.
Regards,
Ali
.
21/06/02
Dear Dr. Sina,
Thank you so much for your response! And thank you for protecting
my anonymity in the website. Lynn is my middle name and my monniker
on the web. I shall try what you suggest. In fact, I tried to
send something from your website tonight...but I think there's some kind
of rot.
I will try again tomorrow. You see..I want to send her your
testimony. And I shall, but in the spirit you suggested, as someone
who doesn't understand...I shall ask her to explain.
Yet, my heart aches. I wish I could be more...honest. But I
know if I confront this dear woman, she will turn me out. Dr. Sina,
you don't know me from anyone else in the world...and I thank you for
taking time with me. But I ache and hurt all over for Fatima and her
family. I wish there was an EASY way to show these good people the
truth. Nevertheless, you are correct. If I go in with my
western attitude and John Wayne guns blazing, all is lost. Sir..they
are such loving people! Good and kind and humble. They have
taught me many things about my own pride and selfishness. Now, I'm
getting maudlin. Anyway, I shall follow your advice. I hope it
works. These people are too good to be bound in slavery.
Lynn
Dear Lynn,
You wrote that I don't know you
from anyone else. But of course I know you. You are my dear sister in
humanity. So is Fatima. We are all blood related. We are all bound by
love.
Each time I come to know a
person from close, I see his or her humanness, his or her vulnerability,
fears, hopes, aspirations and sadness. I see myself reflected in each
human being. This tells me that even those whom I never saw are just like
me with the same qualities and I love them even I had no chance to know
them yet.
I am touched by the love that
you feel for your friend Fatima. But please do not let your desire to
guide her out of the slavery of Islam make her resent you. There is no
truth worth destroying a loving relationship for. Love and friendship is
more precious than any truth. be very tactful with your friend. If you
sense that she is sensitive to the issue, forget it and never raise the
subject again. If she and her family are such wonderful people as you
describe them, they will be wonderful people even if they are Muslims.
Islam will only make those who have propensity to do evil to do evil
things. Those who are good naturally will never do evil even though they
are Muslims. Let her find the truth through other people. She will
eventually see our site. this site is growing very fast and is being read
by thousands of people daily. There are some people who have offered to
translate parts of it in other languages. We will become a force to be reckoned
by the Muslims. It is just a matter of time that our message reach the
entire Muslim world and millions of them will not only abandon Islam
but will join our campaign to wean their brothers and sisters from
it.
All you have to do is shower
your friend with love. But you can help those whom you do not know through
the Internet. This is a powerful tool. We can bring the renascence to the
Islamic world and eradicate Islam with the help of the Internet. I think
this site has helped thousands of people so far to see the real face of
Islam and many Muslims have abandoned Islam thanks to what they read here.
Please join our forum and join our effort to spread this message.
Take care
Ali Sina
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
June 14, 2002
Dear Ali:
There is an organization by the name of Jewish Task
Force and their website is JTF.ORG. The chairman predicted on September
11th 1994 that terrorists would come back and destroy the WTC and kill
thousands of Americans. You can download the show in which he said this on
his website. Now he predicts America will be hit with nuclear weapons. Do
you believe this will happen?
--
Ali Sina responds:
Yes I do! One does not have to
be a psychic to predict that this will happen. If you read my writings
dated prior to the September 11 event you will see that I predicted that
terrorism would hit New York and the rest of the Western cities.
The Bush administration, just
like all its predecessors has it all wrong. They try to make a distinction
between Islam and Islamic terrorism. The fact is that one cannot fight
against terrorism without fighting Islam.
People of America as well as
people of other western countries must take this cotton out of their ears.
They are targets of Islamic terrorists and they will die by millions. They cannot eliminate this terrorism unless they eliminate Islam. The
terrorists are not just the Middle Easterners. They could by any American
gangster converted to Islam.
The ONLY way to fight terrorism
is to weaken their belief. Good people who happen to be born Muslims will
leave Islam when they come to know the truth. They will be shocked, they
will go in denial, they will be disheartened, dismayed, angered but
eventually they will see the truth and will leave Islam. When the masses
of Muslims start to leave Islam the whole Islam will crumble under its own
weight and like a tower of cards it will come down.
Islam is a religion based
completely on lies. We can eradicate it with truth. Truth is more powerful
than lies just as light is more powerful than darkness and it will
eventually win. Today we have young people who strap bombs to their bodies
and explode to kill other innocent people because they believe Islam is a
true religion and they will be rewarded in hereafter. They believe Islam
is a true religion not because they read the Quran or know anything about
Islam. They believe so because they think Islam is the fastest growing
religion and sure if others find Islam to be good and convert, it must be
good. . The truth is that Muslims are the fastest breading people, but
they interpret this as Islam being the fastest growing religion. This
gives them all the assurances that Islam is true and worth dying for. What
will happen when millions of Muslims publicly declare their disbelief in
Islam? Do you think the suicide bombers will continue to give up their
lives for a dubious afterlife when they see everywhere Muslims are leaving
Islam? I doubt so.
Every age has its own problem.
Today’s problem is Islam. Eradicating this cult is the greatest cause
that peace loving men and women must dedicate themselves to. Letting Islam
unharmed means death for millions of humanity. This is a high price to pay
for our inertia and negligently trying to appease Muslims.
I earnestly call upon the
awakened people of the world to not rest until Islam is eradicated. Yes we
can eradicate Islam in one generation. It takes only one generation or
less for Islam to be completely wiped out. But we have to work together
towards that end. There is no time to waste. This is no time to rest. The
good news is that each Muslim who is awakened becomes our ally. He or she,
like you and I, becomes another soldier in this army of light. We have set
in motion a movement… a movement that is destined to bring peace to
humanity. Peace at last,… peace at last,… peace at last….
.. |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
June 12, 2002
Like
you, I was born in Iran However, unlike you I was born into a Christian
family. My family moved to
the United States in 1964. Like most Armenian Christians in Iran, I knew
nothing about Islam. I began
to learn about Islam while attending college in the United States.
Having developed an interest in comparative religion. I continued
to study Islam through books, newspapers, and the Internet.
As a result I found your web site.
I
had an Arabic Quran and I purchased an Arabic-English Dictionary.
I even had some Muslim friends in school teach me how to pronounce
some of the Arabic words in the Quran. It was an Iranian who brought to my
attention Mohammed’s moral character. Your web site has so far been the
most informative and most honest one that I have examined on the subject
of Islam. I re-examined the
Quran and found that what you are saying is true.
Unlike
most Christians in Iran my grandparents survived the Turkish atrocities
against Armenian Christians in the Ottoman Empire during WW1. They later migrated to Iran.
I learned to hate Turks without realizing that Islam was the
Ideology that drove them to conquer land in Iran, Anatolia and the Balkan
Peninsula. Islam also drove
them to commit atrocities against other non-Muslims.
Now I know better and I do not hate Turks.
Only
in a non-Islamic country is a kafir like me allowed to read the Quran with
a critical mind. When I first
read the ninth surah of the Quran in it’s English translation, I threw
the book at the wall. I
didn't learn about the full evil of Islam until I read your web site.
Please read the following quotation.
Moreover,
the Turks caused one of the greatest genocides of history. In 1915, irked
by the Christian Armenians within the Ottoman Empire, the Turks
intentionally deported the whole population of Turkish Armenia numbering
1,750,000 to Syria and Mesopotamia, to mainly desert areas in which there
was little hope of survival. In this manner, 600,000 Armenians died, a
stunning 1/3 of the whole Armenian population. This horrific "final
solution" to the Christian Armenian "problem" was
consciously imitated by the Nazis one generation later in response to the
Jewish "problem." If you can't convert them, kill them. Justice
has never been done for the Armenians either, and as a people to this day,
they hate the Turks, possibly even more than the Greeks, Serbs, and
Bulgarians (who the Turks at least did not try to kill them off
This
quotation is from the following web site about jihad. It reminds me of
what Mohammed did to the Banu Qurayza Jews.
I learned from your web site that Ali, the 4th khalifa,
did the same to Iranians back in the 7th century. Most of my Armenian friends are ignorant of the
doctrine of Jihad. The Quran
is never quoted in any Armenian web sites on the Turkish persecution of
the Armenians. I did find out from an Armenian site that Ottoman declared
a Jihad during WWI
Have
any Islamic scholars condemned the Turkish Atrocities as being UN-Islamic?
Have any Islamic scholars condemned the Nazi German genocide of the Jews?
Have any Islamic scholars condemned the destruction of the World
Trade Center as being UN-Islamic?
I
believe the following. Muslims
or people from Islamic countries are not the only ones that need to be
educated about the evil of Islam. Many
Christians from Islamic countries, who I believe are ignorant of Islam,
are sympathetic with Arab (Muslim) causes.
Americans are the most ignorant of Islam and Jihad.
Your cause needs more than attention from Muslims.
Your cause needs world attention!
My
question to you is what can I do to peacefully fight this bad idea known
as Islam? Do you have any
suggestions?
Sincerely
James
Dear James
You are absolutely right.
Muslims are not evil. It is Islam that drives them to commit crimes.
What you defined as my cause is
not actually my cause. It is the cause of humanity. All Humanity must come
together and eradicate this last bastion of evil. This responsibility of
course is more upon the shoulders of ex-Muslims. But the rest of the world
should view Muslims as the main victims of Islam and be more sympathetic
to our cause.
Now as for your question what
could you do, the answer is you could do a lot. You could speak out and
tell the truth wherever you find the opportunity. Do not allow the
perpetuation of the lie “Islam is a religion of peace, which is
misunderstood”. Stand firmly and correct those who want to appease
everyone and rather be politically correct than be truthful. Those who
think by praising Islam and calling it a religion of peace they can
eventually make Muslims more peaceful are committing a grave mistake. That
is foolish. Islam is what is taught is Quran and not what Tony Blair,
George W. Bush or the moral relativists apologists of Islam such as Karen
Armstrong and her ilk tell us.
Call the talk shows, write to
your local newspaper, and let the world know the truth for only the truth
will set us free from Islamic terrorism.
The number of people who have
realized Islam is evil and it must go for the sake of the peace is
increasing daily. Some of us have even formed an organization to combat
the Islamic lies. Join us and help us in our efforts. We plan to create
different chapters of the faithfreedom.org in different languages. See
what you can do. Can you, for example, translate some of the articles or
write articles in other languages? Can you take the responsibility of
managing the faithfreedom.org in another language? Soon we will have radio
programs, can you help with some of the productions? You have to take the
initiative and see what you can do. Although I prefer that those who want
to help help with their own time and expertise, I also acknowledge that
there are those who do not have time but still want to help. For these
friends I am setting up a fund where they can contribute monetarily. So
far I was the only contributor to this site, but I realize that in order
to grow and take our message to the entire world, I have to team up with
others. Islam can be eradicated in one generation, but certainly it takes
more than one man to do it.
Ali Sina
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06/11/02
Dear Ali,
I am writing this in the hope that you will answer me some time soon...
What is your opinion of Guru Nanak of Sikhism (born in 1469) and
his holy book the Guru Granth Sahib? Our Guru was a man who studied Islam
and Hinduism continuosly throughout his life. In his book he praises
Islam and Muslims and has utmost respect for the character of Mohammed. He
even at one point calls Mohammed "the friend of God". Our Guru
was a very wise man, a spiritual man whom I admire much. There is no way
he could be wrong about Mohammed. How do you explain his views concerning
Mohammed?
Also what do you have to say concerning Mahatma Ghandi's views as
expressed in 'Young India' :
"I wanted to know the best of one who holds today undisputed
sway over the hearts of millions of mankind ... I became more than
convinced that it was not the sword that won a place for Islam in those
days in the scheme of life. It was the rigid simplicity, the utter
self-effacement of the Prophet, the scrupulous regard for his pledges, his
intense devotion to his friends and followers, his intrepidity, his
fearlessness, his absolute trust in God and in his own mission. These and
not the sword carried everything before them and surmounted every
obstacle. When I closed the 2nd volume (of the prophet's biography), I was
sorry there was not more for me to read of the great life."
Please do answer me some time soon.
Yours patiently,
Kehmet.
Dear Kehmet,
When we believe in someone it
is hard for us to be objective as the love of that person truly blinds us
to the truth. For you Guru Nanak is a holy person who could not err. The
truth is that we are all humans and no one is infallible. The only way for
you to find out whether Guru Nanak’s opinion of Muhammad was right or
wrong it to read about Muhammad and be the judge. The humanity is in this
miserable shape because we are all “followers”. We cannot think on our
own but rather want to see what our guru, prophet or messenger says.
Mahatama Gandhi is my hero. But
he was wrong too. He did never study the Quran. He was a politician who
said these words to appease Muslims and bring about the unity of India. If
he truly believed that Muhammad was such great person, he would have
become a Muslim.
Regards
Ali Sina
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
0610/02
Dear Ali:
Do you believe that the United States was wrong in
going to war with the Iraqis in the Persian gulf war?
The united states did not liberate Kuwait because of
humanitarian reasons but because of its oil interests.
Do you believe that Iraq had a right to take over
Kuwait? Maybe it was right because Kuwaitis are Arabs and so are Iraqis.
Why should they stay separated if Kuwait was created for reasons of
politics.
I agree with you about the Quran and Islam but I have
to admit that the United States has done some pretty evil things. I know
that Muslims would still have the same hatred they have for infidels even
if the infidels never did anything to them but do you believe the United
States has done bad things to the Middle East?
One last question: I heard that the United States put
the Taliban in power. Please tell me that this is not true.
Pedros
Dear Pedros,
I am short in time and I am not
a politician. My opinion about these questions is irrelevant to my cause.
Nevertheless I will answer briefly.
No I do not think USA was wrong
in attacking Iraq and I do not think that Saddam had any right to invade
Kuwait. No country must be allowed to invade another country and annex it
without the will of the people who live there.
Now I do not agree with you
that USA liberated Kuwait only for oil. Saddam is a maniac and letting him
gain power is a mistake. For the peace of the world it is imperative to
keep him at bay. But can you tell me why USA and allies attacked
Yugoslavia to liberate Kosovo and Bosnia? Certainly there was no oil there
and that war was pure economical loss for the NATO. I wish we were a
little bit fairer in our judgment.
However this does not mean that
the US is a saint. America has done many mistakes and some of them were
evil.
I believe UK, France and most
European countries have evil policies towards the developing countries. I
am not talking about the Opium war in China or the era of colonization. I
am not even talking about the malicious hand of UK and its role in
persuading the US to overthrow the government of Dr. Mossadegh and install
the puppet regime of M.R. Pahlavi. I am talking about the present. These
European countries, heralded by the UK are shamelessly making lucrative
deals with the criminal regime of Islamic Republic of Iran and have no
concern of the fact that their business associates are enriching
themselves by dragging the country in poverty and keeping the Iranians in
prisons. These European countries think only of their profits and are not
concerned at all if that profit is gained through the blood of millions of
people.
USA is guilty too. America has
committed huge mistakes all due to the short sightedness of its
policymakers. These mistakes have eventually come to hunt them. During the
second half of the last century, America suffocated the voices of the
people in many country and supported dictators such as Pinoshe, Noriega,
Saddam Hussein, Suharto, Markos, the Taliban or M.R. Pahlavi. All these
policies proved to be detrimental for USA in the long run.
Take for example the situation
in Iran. In 1953, CIA funded a cope against the democratically elected
government of Dr. Mossadeq. They did not like democracy in Iran because
through democracy the commies used to participate in the government. The
UK of course had its own agenda in persuading America to overthrow the
government of Dr. Mossadeq. They wanted free oil and were not pleased when
Dr. Mssadeq nationalized the oil.
But the wrong policy of the
America in its deal with Iran came to hunt her half a century later. Iran
instead of becoming a democracy became a dictatorship. The pressure
mounded and any voice of dissent was dealt with harshly. Eventually people
got fed up of dictatorship and in the hope of gaining their freedom made a
revolution and kicked the shah out. But people, who were kept in total
ignorance, had no political savvy. Ignorant people do what ignorant people
do. They trusted a devil like Khomeini just to get rid of Shah and the
result was disastrous. Over a million people were killed and millions more
became refugees while hundreds of thousands of Iranians are kept in
prisons, tortured and beaten.
However, America paid also for
its hand in meddling with Iran’s democracy. The rise of Islamic
fundamentalism created a wave of fundamentalism throughout the Islamic
world. Bin Ladden, who was also one day on the pay roll of the USA,
confessed that it was the success of Khomeini that inspired him to peruse
Islam as a tool to for power. Eventually this very Bin Ladden attacked USA
and killed thousands of innocent Americans in the tragedy of 9/11.
Do you see how narrow minded,
short sighted American politicians half a century ago put in motion the
series of events that eventually like a boomerang came back to hit America
50 years later?
Do you think America has leaned
her lesson? I doubt it. Even today, I have the feeling that the
Administration of G.W.Bush is secretly talking with Reza Pahlavi and
instead of supporting the uprising of the people of Iran, are planning to
help him come to power.
If America wants to gain the
trust of the people in the developing countries, it must take the side of
the people and support the democratic movements within those countries.
But they keep supporting dictators and thus alienate the people. Then they
wonder why most of the people of the world do not like America.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
06 Jun 2002
Dear
Dr. Sina,
I
am a Malaysian and I want to commend and thank you for your courage to
enlighten the world of the evils of Islam which my country state religion.
I find that our Malay indigenous culture is dying and is gradually being
replaced by an Arabic culture. It is crazy that Arabic languages are
introduced in my country schools where the main commerce and industrial
dealings are with non-Arabic nations. Malay indigenous dresses and dances
are now considered “haram” forbidden or un-Islamic. Most Muslims from
middles east and even Pakistan considers Malaysia as a progressive Islamic
country – a role model to emulate and yet our nation is gradually
implementing the restrictive
and unjust laws that strangles Islamic nations like Pakistan and Saudi
Arabia. See below recent Malaysia news articles : (Access to the newspaper
article –30 days archives requires free membership which is free)
concerning the implementation of the “Hadd or Hudud” penal code of the
Islamic laws, replacing the penal code based on the British system.
Terengganu is one of the important Malaysian states rich in oil.
Besides
thanking you for your website, my other reason for writing is that I hope
you can help me. I have been recommending your website at www.faithfreedom
.org to my friends since I discovered it a month ago. Your website helped
me to overcome my political correctness of refraining from calling Islam
an evil religion. You very clearly distinguished the difference between
hating the ideologue of an inherent evil religion, and not hating the
blind followers. I have been visiting your faithfreedom website almost
daily until last Tuesday 4 June, 2002. Unless the faithfreedom website is
having technical problems since Tuesday, I believe Malaysians access to
your webpage is now being blocked by the Islamic authorities who run our
bureaucracy. I wonder if this
move which contradicts the assurance (not to practice censorship of the
internet) given by the Malaysian government to western IT companies
(including Microsoft) who invest here, can be brought to the
attention of the media and hopefully pressurize the Malaysian authorities
to allow access to your website. Apparently your website is considered
more dangerous that the pornographic websites that are freely accessible
to Malaysians.
I
know I can get some of the stuff from the rationalthinking website, but is
there a mirror webpage of faithfreedom that I can access to? Another
possibility is to email me the new articles so that I can pass it around
to my friends who would love to receive them.
Please
keep my email address confidential as I am sure you’ll understand that
the evil that is spawned by this religion knows no bounds and I can easily
be traced and targeted.
Yours
truly,
Nicolei
Dear Nicolei,
Faithfreedom.org
was down for three days because we were moving to a new server. I
apologize for the inconvenience.
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| |
|