|
< part
1
Mubahila Part
III
This is a continuation of my discussion on mubahila (cursing one
another so the one who is in error die) Mr. Shabir Bhatti wrote:
What will you do Mr. Sina, if i call your parents, liars, rapists, mad
and all that you called my beloved Muhammad (SAW) what will you do? I
love my prophet a thousand times more than my parents, so can you
imagine how i fell at the moment about you, you have no idea.
Mr. Bhatti,
I was there one day too and I am familiar with what you feel. The truth is
that Muhammad is not your parent. He even disowned his adopted son and
made his god say, Muhammad is not the father of anyone. Muhammad is no one
to you or to me. My ancestors prided themselves to be the decedents of
him, but if you do some math you’ll see that after about ten generations
basically no trace of his gene was left in those who claimed to be his
descendents. Divide 1 by 2 and keep dividing the result by 2 for ten
times. What is left is less than one in one thousand. After 1400 years no
one can claim to be related to Muhammad. The trace of his genes in his so
called decedents is less than a drop in an ocean. Therefore comparing
Muhammad to your parents is absurd.
What you have is a mental bondage. You are like an addict that depends on
his drug and if that drug is taken away from him, he throws fits and
tantrums. My goal is to wean Muslims from this mind numbing drug and set
them free so they do not lose their sanity and do not act like savage
anytime anyone says something about Muhammad. The relationship Muslims
have to Muhammad is not healthy. There is a remedy to that. It is called
truth. Once Muslims are exposed to truth and they can see who Muhammad
was, they will recover from this mental sickness.
Muhammad was a narcissist who invented a personality cult around himself
so he could be praised and loved. Allah was his own alter ego. That man
was emotionally disturbed. He invented Islam so through it he could garner
the attention and respect of people. To understand Muhammad you have to
study the biography of other narcissists such as Jim Johns, David Koresh,
Joseph Koni, Charles Manson and Shoko Asahara. These insane people also
created a personality cult around them selves and were worshiped by their
brainwashed followers. Once you come to see the truth about Muhammad you
will have no other feeling but despise for that degenerate criminal. Then
you will be very grateful to me for setting you free from this mental
bondage and will see me as your best friend and not as someone to curse
and wish to die.
The Quran, you say was written by Muhammad (SAW) and not God. In that
case I cannot imagine how someone who was a narcissist, a misogynist, a
rapist, a pedophile, a lecher, a torturer, a mass murderer, a cult
leader, an assassin, a terrorist, a mad man and a looter, 1400 years ago
could have written a book in such rich Arabic and so consistent over two
decades.
First of all the Quran is not a rich book in any sense. It is clear that
the author of this book was very ignorant and an unlettered person. He
probably had some basic familiarity with reading but most certainly he was
not an erudite person. We have texts coming to us from antiquity that
demonstrate the erudition of their authors. The Quran does not measure up.
It is an editor's nightmare. Furthermore this book is full of errors and
inconsistencies. In fact it is so confused that you can’t understand it
unless you consult tafseer and hadith. Muhammad’s words also kept
changing, to such an extent that Muslim scholars created an entire
“science” known as nasikh wa mansookh (the abrogator and the
abrogated.) In fact the Quran itself testifies that it is not a consistent
book. Verse 2:106 says:
“None of Our revelations do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, but
We substitute something better or similar.”
How can you say the Quran has been consistent for twenty years when the
Quran itself denies that claim?
Do you think that if you die within the period of the mubahila, your
followers will think it was just a coincidence? Think again Mr. Sina and
this time consider the human psychology.
Mr. Bhatti, I do not have followers. I have not started any religion to
have followers. I have readers and you are one of them. Some of my readers
agree with what I say and some don’t.
Of course if I die within these 90 days that you are praying for my death
no one in his right mind would think I died because of that. Is God a
child play? How can the maker of this universe depend on the whims of his
creatures? How can you pretend that tiny beings such as us can influence
the will of an almighty God who allegedly is the maker of this incredibly
immense universe? Who the hell you think we are to have such powers to
alter God's plans? If God wants to take the life of someone he knows when.
He does not need his creatures to tell him what to do.
Is there any guarantee that without your curses I will survive these 90
days so we can deduce that if I die it is because of your curses? On the
contrary, if I don’t die it is clear that your curses were not answered
and your religion is false. In this bet, you will either lose or gain
nothing. However, if after these 90 days I stay alive and you start
doubting Muhammad, you will be a winner. You will lose your bet but you
may win your freedom. That would be a major victory.
If you die within this period of time 90% of your followers will stray
away believe you were a liar. Trust me, when it happens, it will happen
in such a way that all will see and all shall believe. Inshallah.
Please Add this to your site without editing, if you have the balls to
which i believe you do.
Nobody is following me. I am inviting everyone to use their own brains.
No one accepts anything I say because of my authority. I have not laid any
claim to any authority. I am an ordinary person with no hidden knowledge.
Everything I know I learned from others. If what I say makes sense to my
readers and they find it to be reasonable, they will accept it, but if
what I say is irrational and unfounded no one will accept it. Suppose I
die, why should any sane person assume I died because of your curses? I am
not praying for your death, but can you be sure that you will be alive in
the next 90 days? Just as you can’t give such assurances, I can’t too.
If either one of us dies, it does not mean that that person was wrong.
Those who are wrong and those who are right die equally. When death comes
it does not question who is right and who is wrong. We all die and we
don’t know when it will happen. The truth of something must be
established by proof and not by my death. Imagine I tell you there is life
on Mars and you deny it saying prove it. Is it rational to say let us
curse each other so the one who is mistaken dies and we find the truth?
Isn’t that laughable? Mubahila is a stupid and ludicrous. It is not
befitting for rational people living in the 21st century to believe in
this nonsense.
You gave your word that if after 90 days I am still alive, you will leave
Islam. I know it won’t happen. I know the mind of the believer and how
it is shackled. However, I hope this will create doubt in you and you will
start reading the articles posted in FFI and searching the truth. This
could be a turning point but you must do your homework.
< Back |
