The Contaminated Soul
A
debate with Imtiaz Taher
Date: November 13, 2004
Mr. Ali Sina:
I came across your site and am simply appalled by
the way you spewed your hatred 'bout a particular religion. Albeit
misguided, I commend your research. You have garnered all these
logics and misinterpretations without providing a viable solution,
alternative whatsoever (guess you are not that smart!......you can
talk the talk but not walk the walk....coming to think 'bout it,
how can you?
|
Dear
Imtiaz
If
what I say is erroneous. You are welcome to correct me. If you prove me
wrong I will remove this site.
The
viable solution is to leave Islam. The alternative is holocaust and death
of millions of people.
None of us are able to achieve such kinda feat).
All you could do is hurt the cherished beliefs of people and give
a sick pleasure to people who find your site to be amusing (at the
expense of my religion of course). |
I will have to disagree with you hear. Why do you
think I can’t achieve my goal? After all don’t you believe that truth
is more powerful than lies and light will win over darkness? If what I say
is truth I will succeed and if it is lie then you or someone must be able
to prove me wrong. I am convinced most of the people prefer the truth over
lies and once the lies of Islam becomes manifest the majority of the
Muslims will start leaving it. The exodus has already begun and it is
gaining momentum. I bet many of us will see the defeat of Islam in our
lifetime.
What's the difference between the mullahs you
condemn and you? Both of you are hate filled and blinded by your
faith. And you call yourself 'Humanist', 'Rational thinking'. Nice
adjectives! Congratulations! |
If you don’t see the difference then you have
not read or understood anything I wrote. The Mullahs sell a lie to enslave
the people. I give away the truth to free them from their slavery of mind
without asking anything in return. They enrich themselves by exploiting
the gullible and the foolhardy, I have sacrificed a lot of my personal
pleasures, comfort and wealth and reduced my lifestyle to the bare minimum
to carry on this sacred mission. We
are on opposite poles.
My parting question is.......You are damn smart
to decipher all the vagueness of my religion....Great!......but
someone was smart enough to design your superior
intellect..........isn't he a bit more smart than you are? |
That is entirely a different question. For the
moment I agree with you that such guy exists. I am not here disputing his
existence or non-existence? My
point is that Muhammad was a liar and an impostor. I have no problem if
you want to believe in God.
Now my question to you is, can you prove Muhammad
is sent by God? That is the question. Please think about it. What proof he
gave for his claim? None! There is no proof. Only intimidation; only fear
mongering; only empty promises! But where is the proof?
May Allah have pity on your contaminated
soul. |
How do you know my soul is contaminated? In
my “religion” a contaminated soul is one who separates the children of
Man on the bases of their religion, sex, race, caste or nationality and
calls on one to hate the others. Islam is guilty of the first two
discriminations and apartheids, but not me. A contaminated soul is one who
hates mankind, like hating the Jews, the Kafirs, the idolaters, etc.
Muslims are guilty of that, but not me. A contaminated soul is an old man
who lusts after a 9 year old girl. Muhammad did that, but not me. A
contaminated soul is one who raids unarmed civilians murders them and
beheads them for their money and then enslaves and sell their children and
wives. Muhammad did that, but not me. A contaminated soul is one who
tortures a young man to make him reveal the whereabouts of the hidden
treasures of his population and then beheads him and after showing his
corpse to his 17 year old bride, takes her to her tent and rapes her in
the same night. Muhammad did that, but not me. How can my soul be
contaminated just for speaking the truth?
You claim yourself to be rational......Tell me,
where is the rationality when you traumatize people with your hate
filled anti-religious remarks? |
Truth is not traumatizing. It is the shattering
of lies that is traumatizing. You are like one who has lived in absolute
darkness all his life and is suddenly taken to the daylight. It hurts. It
hurts because you are not used to light. Once you get used to it you’ll
become delighted and wonder how could you have lived in that darkness for
so long.
If you were so rational.....why don't you expose
the vagueness of the other religions? |
Suppose I do! Does that make you feel better? Why
should you care whether others follow false religions? Do you really
believe that Christianity and Judaism are false? Doesn't this make Islam a
false religion by default? Didn't Muhammad say Moses and Jesus were
prophet? So if that is proven to be false doesn't this mean Muhammad was a
liar? You have to respond to your own conscience. Two wrongs do not make
one right.
Furthermore other religions are not evil. They
are simply lies. Some of those lies are benign lies. Say for example, you
follow Christianity which is a lie and because of that you learn to "love
thy neighbor". What is wrong with that? Wouldn't it be nice if
everyone believed in lie like this? But when you believe in Islamic lies
you start hating everyone and divide mankind between Muslims and Kafirs,
“us” and “them” and this is the source of all evil. Good Muslims
follow the examples set by Muhammad and become terrorists. That is why I
fight Islam. Not because it it a lie, but because it is evil.
Unfortunately, I'm not versed enough and lack the
time to refute your nasty remarks (...cool down! Imtiaz!....:) |
Well, it is your obligation to get your facts
straight. I was also ignorant about Islam all my life and thought it to be
a religion of peace. When I really got to know it, I was shocked and left
it in horror. Do some research and you’ll come to the same conclusion
that I came. Then when others say "May Allah have pity on your
contaminated soul", you’ll smile because you’ve been there, and
done that. :)
Anyways, thanks for traumatizing my coveted
faith......I'll be honest with you......I sincerely hope that you
get what you are asking for in your afterlife (You are smart
enough to get the message.......I hope)
Imtiaz
|
I think if there is an afterlife I will be
handsomely rewarded. I have opened the eyes of many people and I have
never in my life hurt anyone intentionally even though I have been hurt
badly several times. I have helped people whenever I could. Even though
some of them turned back and stabbed me, I always forgave them. In my
“religion” (this is just a way of speech, I am not religious) every
action we do has an echo that reverberates for centuries and millennia. We
all matter. Our words and our actions will endure. Anything we do or say
will expand like the ripples produced by throwing a pebble on the surface
of water. If we do good things, this will bring goodness to the world and
if we do evil, that evil will expand and will survive for ever. Muhammad
sowed the seeds of ignorance, hate and evil. 1400 years later, we are
still suffering the consequences of that evil. I am sowing the seeds of
love, enlightenment and goodness. These will last too. So I assure you
that if there is an afterlife and a judgment, Muhammad is in the dept of
hell being tortured along with Hitler and the most despicable criminals
ever walked on this planet. But I go to my grave with the certainty that
if there is a life after death, I will enter a kingdom of joy, full of
love and happiness. Muhammad sowed hatred and hatred he will reap. I am
sowing love and love I shall reap.
I tell the truth and I can prove what I say, but
Muhammad told lies and none of his beguiled and benighted followers is
able to prove any of his claims.
|