Christians
in the Cross Hairs
For Egypt's Copts, Life Is Getting Harder
Robert
Christmas may be anything but merry for
Egypt's Christians. They are increasingly facing a harder time living
under anti-conversion laws and legal discrimination. Not until Dec. 3,
for instance, did police release the last of a group of 22 converts
who had been arrested in late October, their only crime being an
attempt to convert to Christianity from Islam, the Britain-based
Barnabas Fund reported. Mariam Girgis Makar, the last detainee, was
released on bail for 1,000 Egyptian pounds ($162).
According to the Barnabas Fund in its Dec. 4 report, the converts were
arrested on charges related to falsifying their names on documents. In
Egypt, a Christian who converts to Islam can change identification
papers, inserting a new Muslim name within 24 hours. But there is no
reciprocal arrangement for a Muslim who converts to Christianity. All
citizens are required to have listed on their identity card whether
they are Christian or Muslim.
According to Helmy Guirguis, president of the United Kingdom Coptic
Association, Muslims who convert to Christianity and don't change
their names are forced to live a double life. "They convert, keep
their [Muslim] names ... go to church and take communion, [but] when
they go out of the church, they behave like classic Muslims," he
said in an interview with Cybercast News Service published Oct. 29.
Usually, only the priests know about their true identity, Guirguis
said. Converts are unable to befriend other congregants unless they
too are converts living a secret life, he noted. If discovered and
arrested, the converts are tortured and forced to reveal the
identities of accomplices and other converts, Guirguis added.
On Dec. 2 the Barnabas Fund publicized another case of persecution,
involving a convert's Christian husband who was arrested while trying
to leave Egypt. On Nov. 28, Bolis Rezek-Allah tried to escape what the
Barnabas Fund termed "the mounting persecution he is suffering at
the hands of the Egyptian authorities because of his marriage to Enas
Badawi, a Christian converted from a Muslim background."
The press release explained that he was put in the custody of Hussein
Gohar, a security officer noted for his vindictive behavior to
converts from Islam. Gohar has reportedly threatened Rezek-Allah that
he will track down his wife Enas and execute her in front of her
husband. Rezek-Allah was eventually released, but police say they will
continue to block him from leaving the country even though he has the
correct documentation to leave for Canada.
Rezek-Allah troubles started last summer when he was arrested on the
charge of marrying a Muslim. It is illegal under Egypt's Islamic law
for a Christian man to marry a Muslim. Badawi had in fact converted to
Christianity before the marriage, but the Egyptian authorities had
failed to recognize her conversion.
Double standards
The organization International Christian Concern calculates that
Muslims make up 85.4% of Egypt's population. The government estimates
the Christian population at 6%, but other sources put it as high as
14.2%. The vast majority of the Christians are members of the Coptic
Church, which existed before the arrival of Islam in Egypt.
Despite being a long-standing sizable minority group in Egypt, Coptic
Christians face numerous difficulties, said a background briefing by
International Christian Concern. A major obstacle is obtaining
permission to build churches. An 1856 decree dating back to the
Ottoman Empire still requires non-Muslims to obtain a presidential
decree to repair, remodel or build a place of worship.
A 1934 decree of the Minister of Interior added more 10 conditions to
the 1856 law. They include not allowing a church to be built within
100 meters of a mosque, requiring the permission of any utility
official when the construction is near that utility, and requiring
that none of the Muslim neighbors object to the construction.
Another problematic area deals with names given to children.
Youngsters with Muslim names are automatically enrolled in Islamic
religion classes, regardless of parents' wishes. Children with
traditional Coptic names face the risk of a life of discrimination.
Killers go free
Further evidence of the partiality of the Egyptian legal system came
earlier this year when those accused of a 2000 massacre were
acquitted. A March 4 press release by Freedom House's Center for
Religious Freedom expressed alarm at the decision by an Egyptian court
to acquit those charged in a massacre of 21 Christians in the village
of El-Kosheh in January 2000. The Washington, D.C.-based center also
called on the Egyptian government to investigate police misconduct in
El-Kosheh.
Egypt's State Security Court in Sohag found none of the 95 defendants
guilty of the murders, in what was the largest massacre of Copts in
several decades, according to the Center for Religious Freedom on Feb.
27. The court convicted only two men on manslaughter charges for the
death of a Muslim in the nearby village of Al-Balabish.
A member of the Center Paul Marshall conducted a fact-finding mission
to El-Kosheh in 2000 and interviewed eyewitnesses to the massacre.
They named the murderers, many of whom are still living in the village
and threatening further attacks.
Another example of discrimination against Christians was published in
the November bulletin of the religious rights organization Compass
Direct. The bulletin reported on the case of 19-year-old Ingy Nagy
Edwar. The Coptic teen-ager was kidnapped in September by Muslims who
claim she has now converted to Islam. Her family is being prevented
from contacting her.
In fact, reported Compass Direct, state security police officials went
so far as to temporarily detain her father and other male relatives a
few days after the teen-ager's disappearance. The police accused them
of trying to interfere with her conversion to Islam and showed them an
alleged declaration of conversion to Islam signed by Ingy. Under civil
law, a daughter under age 21 cannot change her religion without the
legal permission of her father.
Ingy's family, who spoke to her by phone in October, believes the teen
is being given mood-altering drugs that make "her personality
different," explained her brother, Nagy Edwar Nagy.
Meanwhile, Christians and Muslims are engaged in a bumper sticker war
in Cairo's streets. The Associated Press on Nov. 29 reported that some
Copts imported fish bumper stickers from the United States. Soon
after, Muslims responded with their own bumper stickers: fish-hungry
sharks.
Emad, a Muslim, laughed when asked about the competing symbols but was
unapologetic about the two shark stickers on his car. "The
Christians had the fish so we responded with the shark. If they want
to portray themselves as weak fishes, OK. We are the strongest,"
said Emad, who would give only his first name.
Recent events show that behind the competition over bumper stickers
lies a far uglier reality. Two thousand years ago Providence advised
Joseph to take Mary and the child Jesus and escape persecution by
fleeing to Egypt. That option no longer exists.