Submitted by Dr Radhasyam Br... on Sat, 05/02/2009 - 09:08
Printer-friendly version
Send to friend
PDF versionby Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
Muslims in Jails
It has been pointed out earlier that when it comes education, land holdings and employment, Muslims are well below their share of the population. But contrastingly, they have a disproportionately high representation when it comes to being in prison. In fact, in many states, Muslims even make up a higher percentage of population in jail than they do outside. "
Muslim percentage of inmates in jails in states is as high as their share in population, in many states, including Gujarat, Maharastra, Jharkhand, Karnataka, it's even higher", says the Sachar Committee Report.
Table III below shows the data forwarded to the Committee by eight states:
Table - III
|
Muslim population (%) |
Convicted & under trial |
In jail for more than 1 year |
In jail for 1-5 years |
In jail for more than 5 tears |
In jail for less than 1 year |
| Assam |
30.9 |
30.0 |
n.a. |
n.a. |
n.a. |
28.1 |
| Kerala |
24.7 |
37.1 |
39.5 |
43.3 |
28.7 |
38.3 |
| Jhharkhand |
13.8 |
17.6 |
14.5 |
37.5 |
8.6 |
14.8 |
| Karnataka |
12.2 |
17.6 |
14.5 |
37.5 |
8.6 |
14.8 |
| Delhi |
11.7 |
27.9 |
23.9 |
23.8 |
24.0 |
29.1 |
| Maharastra |
10.6 |
32.4 |
34.7 |
38.5 |
22.8 |
40.6 |
| Gujarat |
9.1 |
25.1 |
26.2 |
25.8 |
21.9 |
n.a. |
| Tamil Nadu |
5.6 |
9.6 |
10.9 |
10.1 |
10.7 |
7.7 |
The summery for the 8 states, 23.4% of prison inmates are Muslims.
Experts agree that this statistic, a key finding of the Sachar Committee, has major social and political implications. Such a high figure of incarceration, experts say, means further marginalization and isolation of the community, deepening prejudice and distrust.. Though there is no break-up of the nature of crime for which these inmates have been imprisoned, sources said the total number of inmates surveyed is 102,652 and a majority of them are not for terrorism. A dozen of states with significant Muslim population shares were asked to furnish statistics on the number of Muslims in prison, convicted and under trials. West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Andhra Pradesh have not reported back to the Committee and data is available only for eight states that did.
Incidentally West Bengal, UP and Bihar rank at the bottom, when it comes to representation of Muslims in Government employment, including state public sector undertakings and the lower judiciary. But the data presented above (Table III) show that when it comes to Muslims in the prison population, Maharastra, Gujarat and Kerala are the most disproportionate.
In Maharastra, The share of Muslim in total population is 10.6%, while the Muslim share in the total prison inmates is 32.4% .
When comes to those in prison for less than a year, Muslims contribute 40.6%. In Gujarat , the percentage of Muslims in the state is just 9..06%, but they make up over a quarter of all jail inmates.
Assam , the second highest Muslim populated state in the country, after J & K, has 30.9% Muslims, and here, the percentage of Muslims jail inmates is 28.1.
Even Karnataka, which did relatively better than other states in providing jobs to Muslims, shows the same trend: 17.5% of its jail inmates are Muslim as compared with 12.23% of its population.
In Delhi , where Muslims make up 11.7% of the population, they constitute 29.1% of those in jails for less than a year.
"
The debate over these numbers is a complex one", Says Prakash Singh, the former Director General of the Border Security Force (BSF). "
There is unjust suspicion against the police, in cases of terror attacks or communal riots, if the police go after the perpetrators of the violence, and they happen to be mostly Muslims. You cannot, in the name of secularism, expect the police to act in proportion to their population", Mr Singh added.
The data presented above were appeared in the October 29, 2006 edition of The Indian Express, but most surprisingly, it was seen that some of data were deleted in the final Report that was tabled in the Parliament a week later. What prompted the Committee to delete such vital data? There is no doubt that it was done at the instigation of the Congress Party led UPA government to hide the real face of the Muslims from the common people of India . These dishonest politicians, according to their policy of Muslim appeasement, are propagating the entirely wrong information regarding Islam and the Muslims day and night and say that Islam is a religion of peace and the Muslims are good and peaceful citizens of India . Or, in other words, they are trying to cover a hyena with the hide of an innocent lamb. But, as the findings of the Sachar Committee are entirely contrary to their false propaganda, they had no other alternative but to delete the data.
But even a Muslim bureaucrat has objected to this mischievous attempt of the government. Mr Wajahat Habibullah, The Chief Information Commissioner, while commenting on this aspect, said, "
This data should have been included. They may have their reasons for excluding it, but to see the story of the Indian Muslims and the problems faced by the community in totality, it should have formed a part of the report."
Many apologists, simply to hide the criminal mindset of the Muslims, have tried to link the said high incarceration rate of the Muslims to their poverty and said, "
Nearly 44% of urban Muslims, compared to 28% of national average, are lying below poverty line and this wide spread poverty is responsible for their adopting criminal path for earning a living." But the excuse is no longer tenable, because, as has been pointed earlier that a substantial portion of Hindus belonging to the OBC and SC/ST categories are victims of similar level of poverty. But they don't have similar criminal propensity. Others say that poverty deprives the Muslims to engage good lawyers to fight their cases and hence they are imprisoned. That is also not true as in every state, there are legal cells run by the governments that provide legal help to helpless poor people free of cost.
Islam is the real culprit
Though the so called secular politicians of India , for the sake of their policy of Muslim appeasement, not dare to speak the truth, the discussions presented above points to the irrefutable truth:
ISLAM IS THE CULPRIT. What would be the implications of the Sachar Committee Report, is debatable, but there is no doubt that it has uncovered the glaring truth - the entire Muslim community is bleeding under the oppression of Islam. It has unveiled the havoc Islam is causing the Muslims of India. Islam is ruining the Muslims of India, and the world community of Muslims at large, in two major ways: Firstly, it is pulling them from behind in their race for progress and prosperity and secondly, it is turning the Muslims into a community of criminals. It also substantiates the common notion that, it is Muslims who are most oppressed by Islam.
The Muslim clerics brainwash the common Muslims, most of whom are illiterates or scantly educated, that Islam is the best religion on the earth. The teach that Islam is superior to Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism and all other religions and the Koran contains the most up to date massage of God. The question therefore naturally arises - despite following the best religion and the most up to date message of God, Muslims, throughout the world, are so backward in every walk of life. And moreover, why they are so inclined to criminal activities.. Not only in India , everywhere in the world, Muslims top the list of criminals. For example, in most of the Western countries, Muslims share of population is below two digit figure. But in theft, burglary, murder and rape, they are at the top of the list. We shall now delve into the matter a bit to show how Islam is forcing the Muslims to remain backward and how it turns them into criminals.
It should be mentioned here that, Islam is a package and one has to accept or believe in its entirety. One cannot say that I believe such and such portions of the Islamic theology and do not believe in the rest. A believer must have blind faith in every aspect of the creed. He must believe that, the Koran is the words of God and hence beyond any dispute. He must have the blind faith that the contents of the Koran are truth and anything else is false. He must believe that before the revelation of the Koran the entire world was inundated by the darkness of falsehood and ignorance, and through the revelation of the Koran, Allah has separated light of wisdom from the darkness of ignorance. The social laws laid down by Allah in Koran are to obeyed without any alteration and those are divine laws ordained by Allah and hence stand superior to any law formulated by human beings.
So, the Koran says,
"And unto thee have We revealed the Scripture with the truth, confirming whatever Scripture was before it, and a watcher over it. So judge between them by that which Allah hath revealed, and follow not their desires away from the truth which hath come unto thee. For each We have appointed a divine law and a traced-out way. Had Allah willed He could have made you one community. But that He may try you by that which He hath given you (He hath made you as ye are). So vie one with another in good works. Unto Allah ye will all return, and He will then inform you of that wherein ye differ" (5:48).
"So judge between them by that which Allah hath revealed, and follow not their desires, but beware of them lest they seduce thee from some part of that which Allah hath revealed unto thee. And if they turn away, then know that Allah's Will is to smite them for some sin of theirs. Lo! many of mankind are evil-livers" (5:49).
"Is it a judgment of the time of (pagan) ignorance that they are seeking? Who is better than Allah for judgment to a people who have certainty (in their belief)?" (5:50).
So, in the above verses of the Koran, Allah specifically orders the believers to strictly adhere to the laws He has revealed and not to follow laws proclaimed by ordinary human beings. The people who follow the laws created by human beings are evil-livers. During the days of jahelia, or darkness of ignorance, i.e. before the revelation of the Koran, pagans and ignorant people used to follow those laws.
The Islamic Voice is a Bangalore based monthly and its current, or April 2009, edition carries an article Allah's Law and the Law of Ignorance, written by Sayyid Qutb. Perhaps the original version was in Arabic, which has been translated into English by Adil Salahi. In that article the author writes, "
The central point in this verse (5:48) is that no modification of Allah's law and no compromise with regard to its provisions is admissible for any purpose."
The author continues, "In the second part, (of the verse (5:48)) the Prophet is warned against compromising even a portion of what has been revealed to him: "
judge between them in accordance with what Allah has revealed, and do not follow their vain desire; and beware of them lest they tempt you away from any part of what Allah has revealed to you" the warning here is more precise, stricter and stronger, it also states the matter in it true nature, it is a temptation which must be resisted, the choice is either to implement Allah's law in full, or to follow vain desires."
"
Having made it absolutely clear to all believers that nothing of the provisions of Allah's law will compromise for any purpose and under any circumstances, the Surah puts the choices available in contrast. It is either Allah's law or the law of ignorance: there cannot be a meeting ground between the two. Which one will they choose... the implementation of Allah's law and following the way of life He has outlined, or the rule of ignorance and vain desires? "Do they desire to be ruled by the law of pagan ignorance? But for those who are firm in their faith, who can be a better lawgiver than Allah?" the author adds.
To establish the superiority of Allah's law, the author writes, "
For those who are firm in their faith, who can be a better lawgiver than Allah?" Indeed, who can be? Who can claim that he can give people better law than that of Allah? What argument can be given to prove his hollow claim? Can he say that he knows the nature of mankind better than their creator? Can he say that he is more compassionate and sympathetic to mankind than their Lord? Can he say that he knows their interest better than the God of mankind?"
To conclude the article, the author writes, "
It is Islam or ignorance, faith or unfaith, the rule of Allah or the rule of pagan ignorance, those who choose not to judge in accordance with what Allah has revealed are disbelievers, wrongdoers and transgressors. Their subjects who do not accept Allah's law are not believers.. This question must be absolutely clear in every Muslim's mind, unless it is so clear; he will not be able to differentiate between truth and falsehood and will not be able to take one footstep in the right direction.."
So, it is not difficult to understand the message of the article. Any law, not ordained by Allah, is a law of ignorance and hence a Muslim must not follow such a law. Every Muslim must follow the law revealed by Allah because a man can never be a better law-giver than Allah. A Muslim, who refuse to follow the laws of Allah and follows the law of ignorance created by man, is a disbelievers, a wrongdoers and a transgressors, or simply a kafir. At the same time, no amendment, or up dating, or compromising with Allah's law is permitted. How a mortal human being be capable of over-writing, distorting or modifying Allah' law?
Here lies the seed of worldwide backwardness of the Muslim community. Almighty Allah has revealed His divine laws nearly 1400 years ago and every Muslim is bound to follow that rules today without any alteration or modification. Once upon a time, the Christians were also compelled to follow the rules laid down by God in the Bible, because at the end of the New Testament, God said, "
I warn everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book: If anyone adds anything to them, God will add to him the plagues described in this book.. And if anyone takes words away from this book of prophecy, God will take away from his in the tree of life and in the holy city, which are described in this book" (Revelation, 22:18-19).
But During the period of Renaissance, the Christian world could liberate themselves from the clutch of this God's law and the oppression of the Church at the cost of sacrifice of many noble souls. But it is highly debatable whether such a revolution will ever take place in the Islamic world, which would liberate the Muslims from the oppressive Arab religious imperialism, return their right to freedom of speech, liberty and democracy.
(To be continued)
Let tell one thing very
Let tell one thing very clearly. Maximum number of people engaged in criminal activity willingly in India are Muslims. There is no doubt about it. Also they do not take up respectable professions. If they take up one, then there too they engage in illegal activities. I have seen many antique shops owned by muslims where hardly anyone walks in. I always wondered why those items on sale remain there for years more than 4 or 5 years. I still see them there. its the same piece. a friend of me told that these shops are just namesakes for criminal operations by muslims. i have hardly seen a muslims happily accepting a bank cheque or payment by credit card. they always want it in cash. also they hesitate in giving a bill with their tax registration numbers.
a muslim, whether he is educated or not, always lean towards a criminal life. Dr.Haneef is one such perfect example. I know he is involved deeply. so is his two cousins, one died in the bombing incident. even if the government comes out and helps these muslims, they still love their criminal ways. they are worse than a dog's tail. muslims do not join government services, because it leaves a record of them and can be traced. and muslims particularly love the easy money from criminal activities. you can see that all over the world.
quran is the basis for all these abnormalities in islamic communities. salman rushdie was right when he wrote the "Satanic Verses". he pointed out to the world the dark side of quran, muhammad and allah. i hope people wake up and realise that islam, allah and muhammad are Satan in the guise of god. my father realised it long back and got us out of it. hope many realise this soon.
Why are all of you ungrateful
Why are all of you ungrateful infidels so critical and unfair to Islam? Don’t you realize it is a precious gift and mercy from all-wise and all-knowing Allah to mankind? Merciful Allah truly seeks our welfare and happiness. In his wisdom he has done this in a miraculous way that no other religion has ever done.
Wise Allah knows true peace of mind can be achieved only if we are spared the effort of having to think for ourselves. He created Shariah as the solution. In one masterly stroke he has achieved what no other religion has. Total mind control packaged as Shariah. Even Hitler envied the power Allah has over the minds of his followers. Allah has spared us all the pain and effort of having to think for ourselves. Just imagine what peace and contentment our mind feels when we are spared the effort of having to think for ourselves? Allah has done all of our thinking for us. What greater gift could he have given you ingrates? He has asked for no reward except for the Zakaat and the Jizya. Small thanks give ye!
Allah be praised, from the time our eyes awaken first thing in the morning (next to our favorite wife) till we go to sleep at night (taking turns with our different wives) all that we have to do or not to do has been laid down for us. Step-by step detailed instructions by our god-given Shariah laws. So many that it achieves its desired objective of numbing, stunning and shutting down our brains. What to do from the day we are born till the day we die.
Who to, how, when and in which direction to pray. What, when, and what to eat. How to bath and wash. Which foot to use before we enter the toilet, how to squat, what direction to face, what to use to clean up, which foot to use when exiting and which prayers to use to protect us from bad jinns when in this evil, smelly place. It does not end there.
We have our prescribed circle of friends and families laid down for us and also our prescribed enemies, who we should terrorize, extort and slay to promote our way of life. Who to marry, how many, how to beat our wives if they dare be uppity to us, how big the stick or whip should be, how many blows or lashes to give, and how to divorce them speedily to get a fresh batch. Even when we die all is laid down for us. Does it get any better than this?
So what if the lack of thinking for ourselves from birth to death has made us poor, stupid, intolerant, violent, ignorant and backward all over the world. We don’t care because only we the unthinking, blind believers go to our promised heaven. So what if we are the only ones in the whole wide world stupid enough to believe this? It is a small price to pay for 72 yummy chicks, good food and excellent wine. Even 28 handsome lads to pour the good stuff! Unlike your infidel wine, Allah’s wine will give you no nasty hangovers only a great high.
Thank you Allah for sparing us the grave sin of thinking for ourselves which can only lead to the fires of hell and saves us from making even one small mistake! Isn’t Allah great?
And for this great unique gift (don’t any of you dare say curse if you fear hell!) we have one man to thank – Muhammad (#*x!x) a true example of a warrior prophet, outdoing even Joshua. He achieved peace of mind among mankind by naming as enemies those who wanted to think for themselves. Which is why Islam is called a religion of peace – it gives us all the peace of the sword and peace of mind from thinking. We his followers have been given license to rob, rape their women and slay those who dare to exercise their own minds. Till the Day of Judgment! What an example to follow!
(For the benefit of confused Muslims who need constantly to be told what to think, this comment of mine is pure satire and contains not just a grain of truth but a whole beach-full.)
Excellent article.
Excellent article.
#2, waaaa waaaaa - if the
#2, waaaa waaaaa - if the muslims didn't misbehave so much there would be nothing to criticize. Yes, I know you feel you should be above criticism and that is why I suppose you are trying to shut down free speech everywhere by the UN, lawsuits, and other mischief against others.
#3. I agree!
Does anyone have any idea of the stats in Europe, the UK, Canada, Australia and last but not least - the USA? Or are we just too politically correct to be scrutinizing them more sharply?
most of these small buisness
most of these small buisness houses and tea stalls that muslims own are mostly centres for hawala transactions. Its not that there are no Hindu or sikh or christian criminals in India, rather its that the number of muslim criminals is higher than any other group per capita.
Muslims usually take to crime very early in their lives, this I say with the exception of the kashmiri Muslim, because the muslim from kashmir is extremly shrewd and buisness like and has no interest in loosing life or limb or that of his own. The education rate is also much higher in kashmir.
However this is an exception when compared with the rest of the nation where Muslims are usually brought up in ghettos where they are taught to live a life on crime in absence of oppotunities which comes due to the birth rate amogst them.
On an average every muslim family in India has 8-10 children. I am taking a very conservative average here because there are families with 50 children who are fathered by one man.
When a family unit is euivalent to a tribe, it becomes almost impossible to maintain any sorts of standards when it comes to education or possibilities of employement and hence Muslims end up becoming criminals.
There is no big rocket science in learning why Muslims in general and Indian muslims in particular are criminal minded. The infant mortality rate amogst Muslims is the higest as they refuse to inloculize their kids, have very little food the share and a growing number of drug adicts in the Muslims soceity.
Yes this might come as a surprise to you, but the largest number of drug addicts in India are the Muslims. The reasons are apparent, when these Muslim kids see their Hindu and Sikh and Christian counterparts doing well for themselves they are automatically send into a world of misery and self cotepmt and cheap drugs are the only solace.
Hence one thing leads to the other. drugs, crime, theft, rape, these are all interelated activities.
#2 LOL
#2 LOL
Muhammad was a "GodFather".
Muhammad was a "GodFather". His cut was 20% of the loot. Are you still wondering why so many muslims are criminals?
See below Islam in action.
See below Islam in action. Taken from TOI of date.
Brothers kills their sister
LONDON: Ashamed of her growing popularity, two brothers allegedly shot dead their singer sister in Peshawar last week for performing on television.
The murder of Ayman Udas, who was in her early thirties, has shocked the city's cultural community as it symbolises a backlash against women and cultural freedom in an area that is increasingly dominated by Islamic fundamentalists, 'The Sunday Times' reported on Sunday.
Udas sang and wrote compositions in her native Pashto language, spoken in the tribal areas and the North-West Frontier province, she also frequently performed on PTV, the state-run channel.
Despite Udas's popularity her family felt it was sinful for women performing on television and strongly opposed her.
According to the report, her two brothers reportedly entered her flat last week while her husband was out and fired three bullets into her chest. Neither has been caught.
The final song performed by Udas on screen seems to have portended her death. It was entitled, "I died but still live among the living, because I live on in the dreams of my lover."
A divorced mother of two, Udas had remarried ten days before she was murdered.
I request VHP, RSS, BJP and
I request VHP, RSS, BJP and other pro-hindu organizations to take the articles with its comments in ffi, make it into book format, translate into major Indian languages (Urdu, Bengali, Gujarait, Marathi, Punjabi, Oriya, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada & Malayalam) and distribute for a nominal price among the masses to enlighten them the real nature of Islam, the cause of all our troubles in India. Only this kind of work can save India from destruction of Islamisation.
Another news from Times of
Another news from Times of India -
Is Pakistan heading for an Islamic Revolution? Indrani Bagchi - Tuesday April 28, 2009
In 1979, a bunch of Islamic students led the revolution that overthrew the Shah of Iran. In 2009, another bunch of Islamic students, the Taliban, are walking through large parts of Pakistan, and, at gunpoint, pushing for sharia law to be implemented all over Pakistan.
The Taliban are no longer just a bunch of ideological extremists, they are now inextricably mixed up in the protests of farmers, landless labourers and the have-nots in the extremely feudal in the extremely feudal society that Pakistan remains.
This could be just another eyewash, but there is a greater danger here. First, its clearly happening in the absence of a credible political government that can deliver basic services. Therefore, if the Taliban advance far enough, I could envisage a situation a few months down the line, where the Pakistan army could use this threat to take over governance yet again. And as we all know from long painful experience, every time the Pakistan army is in power, militants have been allowed to blossom. Adn all recent reports are full of anecdotal evidence about the radicalisation of the forces.
Second danger: the advancing Taliban are Wahhabi or Deobandi Sunnis, with no patience for other Islamic sects, and Pakistan is still full of them. If extreme Sunni ideology is going to march through Pakistan, it will be deeply blood-stained by the Ahmadiyas, Barelvis, Shias, what have you.
Stay with that thought: in the not-so-distant future, are we looking then at a Talibanised government in Islamabad, striding forth to impose extremist Sunni thought through Pakistan, with a Shia Iran wanting to be leader of the region, next door? Thats not a pretty picture. And we’re not even talking of an India to the east.
Third, the world is worried about an Iran acquiring nuclear weapons? If Pakistan gets Talibanised, you have readymade nuclear arsenal in their hands. If the ayatollahs in Tehran see scary to the world, they will now seem so much more civilized than the Taliban.
And did I forget to mention that the al-Qaida leadership is alive and well inside Pakistan, guarded by the Pakistan security services?
Very informative article, and
Very informative article, and I learned so much also from comments by Ibrahim and Kaalan.
In Holland there are at least 2 groups who are disproportionally criminal and in jail, causing much trouble. The West Indian Antillians and the Moroccans. Religion of Antillians I don't know much about, they seem to have none, or are Christian. Economy is down in Curacao and the more lawless elements come to Holland. The Moroccans are of Islamic origine. Moroccan youths are causing a lot of trouble, dealing drugs, being criminal. Disproportionately that is, not all of them.
So now in India as well as in Iran large numbers of Muslims are drug-addicts? It makes sense, considering their often hopeless outlook. I dread the Taliban's march on Islamabad with its nuclear weapons. No good can come from yet another military coup in Pakistan, I agree.
It is good that the world knows about all these facts and threats.
When the moslems are high on
When the moslems are high on drugs thjey get the same feeling like the prophet! They take a trip on one winged horse to heaven and keep enjoying the company of 72 houries till their drug addicted butt gets kicked in to prison
Demsci wrote: In Holland
Demsci wrote:
In Holland there are at least 2 groups who are disproportionally criminal and in jail, causing much trouble. The West Indian Antillians and the Moroccans. Religion of Antillians I don’t know much about, they seem to have none, or are Christian. Economy is down in Curacao and the more lawless elements come to Holland. The Moroccans are of Islamic origine. Moroccan youths are causing a lot of trouble, dealing drugs, being criminal. Disproportionately that is, not all of them.
Yo forgot to mention rioting, attempted to carry-out a terrorist plot, harassing kafir women, and segregating themselves into areas.